Personalised Formative Assessment in Ukrainian Higher Education: Design and Empirical Evaluation of the SMART-PL Model
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.34190/ecel.25.1.5075Keywords:
personalised formative assessment, remediation feedback, competency-based assessment, Moodle virtual learning environment, Erasmus CBHEAbstract
This paper reports the design, implementation and empirical evaluation of a personalised learning (PL) model developed for Ukrainian higher education during 2022–2025, under the Erasmus+ Capacity Building project SMART-PL – Students’ Personalised Learning Model, Based on the Virtual Learning Environment of Intellectual Tutoring "Learning with No Limits". The project was coordinated by Tallinn University of Technology and implemented by six Ukrainian universities. Two contributions are advanced. The first is a four-stage design pattern for consortium-level PL adoption in transitional higher education systems: comparative benchmarking of European and Ukrainian practice; negotiated guidelines specifying PL principles, actors, stakeholders and a piloting roadmap; an explicit metric framework for knowledge acquisition and academic progression; and platform-mediated piloting through an information-diagnostic Moodle-based platform with instructor-authored, rule-mapped feedback blocks. The second is empirical evidence from a one-semester pilot (mid-January to mid-June 2025) across the six Ukrainian universities, engaging 772 students and 64 academic staff across all ten ESCO-aligned ICT professional qualification areas. Survey response rates of 42–71% exceeded thresholds typically required for generalisable findings in educational research. The Improvement Curve metric – relative score change between consecutive attempts on the same competency-aligned test – showed a median gain of 17% (range 9–38%) between the first and second attempt, with upward trajectories sustained across third, fourth and fifth attempts and second-and-subsequent attempts systematically crossing the platform's competency threshold of approximately 8/20. The evidence supports the claim that system-generated feedback tied to identified knowledge gaps produces measurable and consistent learning gains under repeated attempts. The four-stage design pattern is transferable to other Eastern Partnership and accession-track higher education systems.