Cognitive Barriers in Solving Context-Based Geometry Tasks in an LMS Moodle Environment

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.34190/ecel.25.1.5520

Keywords:

Open-Ended E-assessment, Mathematical Modelling, Geometry Education, Cognitive Barriers, Pre-service Mathematics Teachers

Abstract

Context-based tasks provide an important means of connecting geometric knowledge with real-world situations. Successfully solving such tasks, however, requires more than knowledge of geometric concepts and relationships. Students need to understand the given situation, translate it into an appropriate geometric model, identify the relevant geometric relationships, and subsequently interpret the obtained solution within the original context. Each stage of this process may give rise to specific difficulties and cognitive barriers, which can be reflected in incorrect or incomplete solutions. This process can be viewed within the mathematical modelling cycle described by Blum and Leiß (2007). This study focuses on the analysis of open-ended responses produced by pre-service mathematics teachers when solving context-based geometry tasks in the Synthetic Geometry I course. One of the key topics addressed in the course is loci of points satisfying given conditions. As part of the course, students completed an e-test in the Moodle learning management system consisting of seven open-ended context-based tasks. Solving these tasks required students to translate real-world spatial situations into two-dimensional geometric models, identify the corresponding loci of points, and interpret their solutions in relation to the original problem context. Open-ended responses collected during two implementations of the course were analysed using qualitative content analysis with inductively developed categories. Particular attention was paid to incorrect and incomplete solutions in order to identify recurring error patterns and, on this basis, to characterise potential cognitive barriers arising at different stages of the problem-solving process. The analysis focuses particularly on difficulties related to understanding the problem context, constructing an appropriate geometric model, identifying the relevant locus of points, and interpreting the geometric solution within the original situation. The study highlights the potential of analysing incorrect responses as a means of gaining deeper insight into the geometric reasoning of pre-service mathematics teachers. Identifying cognitive barriers may also contribute to the more targeted design of instruction and e-assessment tasks that support not only the acquisition of geometric knowledge but also the development of students’ ability to mathematically model and interpret real-world situations.

Author Biographies

Katerina Biernatova, University of Ostrava, Faculty of Education

Katerina Biernatova is a Ph.D. student in Information and Communication Technologies in Education at the Faculty of Education, University of Ostrava. Her doctoral research focuses on the integration of electronic testing into mathematics education, with particular attention to its impact on students’ motivation, self-assessment, understanding, and feedback. Her research explores the use of digital assessment tools and learning management systems in mathematics education, particularly in geometry and in the preparation of future mathematics teachers. She is also interested in the diagnostic potential of open-ended e-assessment and the use of students’ responses to identify difficulties and cognitive barriers in mathematical problem solving. Since the academic year 2024/25, Biernatova has also been teaching courses in Analytic and Synthetic Geometry for pre-service mathematics teachers at the University of Ostrava.

Angelika Schmid, University of Ostrava, Faculty of Education

Angelika Schmid is an assistant professor at the Faculty of Education, Comenius University Bratislava, and a researcher at the Department of Mathematics with Didactics, Faculty of Education, University of Ostrava. Her research focuses on mathematics and geometry education, STEAM education, and the integration of digital technologies into teaching and learning, with particular emphasis on inquiry-based and constructivist approaches. Her research employs design-based research, qualitative and quantitative methods, and the analysis of authentic educational data, including video analysis. She has extensive experience with the educational use of GeoGebra, augmented and virtual reality, 3D modelling, and 3D printing, and participates in national and international research and educational projects, including Erasmus+ projects. In her teaching, she is primarily involved in pre-service and in-service teacher education, connecting teaching practice with research-informed innovation and the meaningful use of digital technologies.

Lilla Korenova, Comenius University Bratislava, Faculty of Education

Lilla Korenova is the acting Head of the Department of Didactics of Mathematics and Natural Science and the guarantor of the new study program 'Teaching for Primary Education – Mathematics and Informatics' at the Faculty of Education, Comenius University in Bratislava. She earned her PhD in Theory of Mathematics Education at Comenius University and obtained her habilitation in Mathematics and Computer Science at the University of Debrecen, Hungary. Her research focuses on STEAM education, digital technologies in teaching, mathematics didactics, e-assessment, and e-learning. She has led or participated in several national and international projects supporting innovation in STEAM education. She has authored and co-authored numerous academic and professional publications and has extensive experience in teacher education and training. Professor Korenova serves on editorial boards of international journals and supervises PhD students in mathematics education, ICT in education, and elementary pedagogy.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-07