Cognitive Barriers in Solving Context-Based Geometry Tasks in an LMS Moodle Environment
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.34190/ecel.25.1.5520Keywords:
Open-Ended E-assessment, Mathematical Modelling, Geometry Education, Cognitive Barriers, Pre-service Mathematics TeachersAbstract
Context-based tasks provide an important means of connecting geometric knowledge with real-world situations. Successfully solving such tasks, however, requires more than knowledge of geometric concepts and relationships. Students need to understand the given situation, translate it into an appropriate geometric model, identify the relevant geometric relationships, and subsequently interpret the obtained solution within the original context. Each stage of this process may give rise to specific difficulties and cognitive barriers, which can be reflected in incorrect or incomplete solutions. This process can be viewed within the mathematical modelling cycle described by Blum and Leiß (2007). This study focuses on the analysis of open-ended responses produced by pre-service mathematics teachers when solving context-based geometry tasks in the Synthetic Geometry I course. One of the key topics addressed in the course is loci of points satisfying given conditions. As part of the course, students completed an e-test in the Moodle learning management system consisting of seven open-ended context-based tasks. Solving these tasks required students to translate real-world spatial situations into two-dimensional geometric models, identify the corresponding loci of points, and interpret their solutions in relation to the original problem context. Open-ended responses collected during two implementations of the course were analysed using qualitative content analysis with inductively developed categories. Particular attention was paid to incorrect and incomplete solutions in order to identify recurring error patterns and, on this basis, to characterise potential cognitive barriers arising at different stages of the problem-solving process. The analysis focuses particularly on difficulties related to understanding the problem context, constructing an appropriate geometric model, identifying the relevant locus of points, and interpreting the geometric solution within the original situation. The study highlights the potential of analysing incorrect responses as a means of gaining deeper insight into the geometric reasoning of pre-service mathematics teachers. Identifying cognitive barriers may also contribute to the more targeted design of instruction and e-assessment tasks that support not only the acquisition of geometric knowledge but also the development of students’ ability to mathematically model and interpret real-world situations.